ALGEBRAIC PLAY

                                        


"Mathematics in the primary schools has a good and narrow aim and that is pretty clear in the primary schools. ... However, we have a higher aim. We wish to develop all the resources of the growing child. And the part that mathematics plays is mostly about thinking. Mathematics is a good school of thinking. But what is thinking? The thinking that you can learn in mathematics is, for instance, to handle abstractions. Mathematics is about numbers. Numbers are an abstraction." 

                                                                                           G. Polya, Lecture on Teaching Mathematics


The Sommer Cube (S3) is about seeing Play in operational intelligence equillibrium (not silliness or behaviorist truism) terms, as adaptability (Play = Ashby’s Cybernetic / homeostatic "good regulator”).

Like algebra, solving geometry problems by analytic means (Cartesian Plane):  illumination of diverse problem sets (classes) across a broad range of disciplines. CHALLENGES / GAMES 

S3 is about variations on a theme of square and circle -- flip-flop, a counterpoint of logic and intuition.

A simple block and ball networking system which leverages full-spectrum cognitive / perceptual processing, learning algorithms, and the art of design, with an emphasis on advanced thinking and intuition -- and its reflection upon itself (not "mere facts", but principles):  functional relations, particularly goals and feedback (What information is relevant? What are my assumptions? Are they justified?)


                                                   

Thus, Sis about the need for more learning proficiency than problem solving competence:  situation awareness, creativity, and the careful construction of logical arguments, and their limitations.


The aim of heuristic [S3is to study the methods and rules of discovery and invention .... Heuristic, as an adjective, means 'serving to discover'. ... its purpose is to discover the solution of the present problem. ... What is good education? Systematically giving opportunity to the student to discover things by himself.                                                                                                                                                   

                                                                                                                G. PolyaHow to Solve It (1945)

                  

                     The Smart Block.

                                                        Binary and Analogical Reasoning

                                                        (switch from fixed to changing values).

                                                        The Upgrade.     


                                                                       

S3 is a simple block and ball networking system which leverages full-spectrum cognitive flexibility / perceptual processing   :  learning algorithms, and the art of design, with an emphasis on advanced thinking and intuition -- and self-reflection (not "mere facts", but principles); functional relations, particularly goals and feedback (What information is relevant?  What are my assumptions?  Are they justified?)

                                                         

Exploration of deep causal structure.

Scientifically verifiable Spatial Thinking   (space, representation, process:  multifaceted, interconnecting competencies, human and robottools and learning opportunities are needed, for teachers as well as students, diagnostic as well as development.

In musical (math / pattern) termsSis about polyphony:  simultaneously combining modules, independent in melody (rhythm and contour of ball trajectory) yet interdependent harmonically (periodic variations upon a theme).

From child to super-mathematician, the Smanipulator has only one path:  reason / intuit up the original "evolution of mathematics”  , from things, to abstractions of things, to binaryness, to geometryness, to algebraness, to setness  -- create more sophisticated problem models, know what the laws are.

S3 is about levels of abstraction, pattern, the rule which governs a system or phenomenon, exactly like numeric, musical, or visual relationships; patterns of thought (and their systematic breakdown -- learning requires negative knowledge), intuition, under simultaneous mental (rational and nonrational) and manual rotation.  Apex reasoning, patterns of thought exceeding the parameters normally experienced in logical operations:  where the strategies and tactics are evolutionary.  

S3 are "pattern blocks", which create porus polyhedron "chains" formed by distinct collections of figurative elements:  circles and squares.

A paradigm shift, a hybrid, an orchestration of ideas:  combination of simple puzzle, labyrinth / maze and rolling ball (apparently unrelated, but in equilibrium, exploiting the symmetry of geometry and algebra, to higher and higher levels of abstraction), where intuition, naive commonsense reasoning, is a prerequisite -- logic is necessary but not sufficient 


"Teachers try to convince their students that equations and formulas are more expressive than ordinary words. But it takes years to become proficient at using the language of mathematics, and until then, formulas and equations are in most respects even less trustworthy than commonsense reasoning

                                                                                     Marvin Minsky, Society of Mind


Consequently, S3 demands recognition of sequence / pattern of repeating events formed in accordance with a definite rule(s) -- but different individuals can perceive the same pattern differently, reach different generalizations.

As Galileo put it.


"[The universe] cannot be read until we have learnt the language and become familiar with the characters in which it is written. It is written in mathematical language, and the letters are triangles, circles and other geometrical figures, without which means it is humanly impossible to comprehend a single word." 

                                                                                                     Galileo Galilei, Opere Il Saggiatore, 1623


                                                  


“The psychical entities which seem to serve as elements in thought are certain signs and more or less clear images which can be 'voluntarily' reproduced and combined... this combinatory play [emphasis mine] seems to be the essential feature in productive thought before there is any connection with logical construction in words or other kinds of signs which can be communicated to others."

                                                                        Albert Einstein:  letter to Jacques Hadamard,

                                                                        The Psychology of Invention in the Mathematical Field, 1945 


Thus, S3 is about uncertainty as tool.  

It’s mysterious.

Thus, the fun of S3 and mathematics:  

Do it Yourself.



                                 Distributed Programming Network

             Discovering and Representing A System Of Rules


The exercise of critical thought is fun for scientists and for artists and for musicians.

School is too often not fun.

School is too often about learning -- not thinking.

It's a big secret:  Thinking is good for you.

S3 is a programmable logic component (In Field Programmable Gate Array terms), a combinational (technically “permutational", like a combination lock) logic block which contains four tunnels, effectively an array of unconnected switches to be programmed by the user as the block is rotated in space, which can be connected to other logic blocks to create multiple adaptive, simultaneous, routes by reconfigurable interconnects.

S3 is a dynamic router, an Analog-Binary Processor:  a system of programmable binary (0/1) switches, a “flying junction” (an over-and-under junction of tunnels which weave past each other) housed within a cubical exoskeleton with multiple axes of rotation and alternative, manipulator-controlled ball trajectories, offering exit in all orientations.

Thus, S3 is about continuous switching (synchronous and asynchronous):  nested, dynamic, switching of cognitive and perceptual and mathematical dichotomies, where the manipulator must constantly re-examine reigning assumptions, transcend and control nested and evolving recursion and contradiction, by inventing new propositions (Boolean algebra -- a way of seeing new structures -- fundamental to the design of binary computer circuits and programming language).  Note that individual S3 logic elements do not necessarily have a discrete true / false state at any given time; simple Boolean logic is inadequate for this, thus extensions are required.


                                     The Dialectic 

                                               

S(about human learning proficiency) is an exploration of symmetry, transformation of parts and whole, square and circle -- adaptation to accelerating rates of change and complexity of system and environment.  While Rubik’s Cube (Machine-think:  about problem solving competence), without that paradox, exercises logic, Stopology of paradox demands logic and intuition, naive commonsense reasoning.

The developing S3 network requires constant revision of operational sets and simultaneous consideration of many possibilities from many perspectives: the order of steps is not fixed, there is no algorithm.  (learning requires negative knowledge) 

In Cybernetic terms, the S3 is a tangible demonstration of basic behaviors (consciousness) of the brain through mechanical concepts (switches / logic gates); a cubical maze module (four tunnels = four binary (0/1) switches = gate array) offering a development of choices (control flow) to create linearly independent / dependent paths, using a ball, or symmetry in mathematics.


                     

                        Rolling Ball “Tilt-Switch”                                 Asynchronous Binary Processor (0/1)

Each S3 reorientation simultaneously reprograms the four "gravity feed” tunnels differentially, nonlinearly; each acts as a binary (0/1) logic gate (rolling ball "tilt-switch") to impede (0) / allow (1) ball flow.

(Note that Snonlinearity -- change in one variable which does not produce a directly proportional change in the result -- even in the single S3, is effectively a nonlinear expression / experience which allows one to intuitively graph the output as a curve -- very exciting stuff for the manipulator with a questioning mind.   And that’s just the first S3.)


It demands the manipulator understand and assimilate evolving information about patterns and functional relationships and analyze change in both concrete and hypothetical contexts: a meeting of abstract ideas with the spirit of mathematical rigor.

In logic / mathematical terms, the S3 manipulator must personally (without symbolic / numerical tools) visualize, intuit, reason incommensurate concepts, like Gödel’s Paradox (“this statement is false” requires a broader logical perspective), like the S3, self-referential), like the Pythagorean triangle, 1,1, √2; 1,1,1, √3, and reinvent accordingly (Oops! all numbers are not integers, rational numbers -- let’s look at the bigger picture — think of it as irrational number along a line of possible numbers).

                                   

It’s the same with S3:  connect the abstract with reality, ideas as things, deal systematically with changing patterns of:

Structure and transformation (transformation geometry / symmetry; rotation [turns], reflection [flips], translation [slides], etc.);

Change and motion (Calculus);

Visual or tactile (Geometry);

Operations (Algebra); and

Connections (Graph Theory).

Systematically reinvent the fundamentals of mathematics; create basic strategies, reasoned / intuitive conceptual structures, mathematical abstractions: 


                 "Just WHAT IS ALGEBRAIC THINKING?”

“While it is unclear what the goal "algebra for all" really means, the trickle-down effect of this goal is clear: elementary and middle school mathematics instruction must focus greater attention on preparing all students for challenging middle and high school mathematics programs (Steen, 1992; Chambers, 1994; Silver, 1997). Thus, "algebraic thinking" has become a catch-all phrase for the mathematics teaching and learning that will prepare students for successful experiences in algebra and beyond.

                    “ALGEBRAIC THINKING - ACCORDING TO SOME EXPERTS”

“Battista and Brown (1998): For students to meaningfully utilize algebra, it is essential that instruction focus on sense making, not symbol manipulation. Throughout their mathematical careers, students should have opportunities to reflect on and talk about general procedures performed on numbers and quantities. ...Thinking about numerical procedures starts in elementary grades and continues...until students can eventually express and reflect on the procedures using algebraic symbolism.

Greenes and Findell (1998): The big ideas of algebraic thinking involves representation, proportional reasoning, balance, meaning of variable, patterns and functions, inductive reasoning, and deductive reasoning.

Herbert and Brown (1997): Algebraic thinking is using mathematical symbols and tools to analyze different situations by (1) extracting information from the situation...(2) representing that information mathematically in words, diagrams, tables, graphs, and equations; and (3) interpreting and applying mathematical findings, such as solving for unknowns, testing conjectures, and identifying functional relationships.

Kaput (NCTM, 1993): Algebraic thinking involves the construction and representation of patterns and regularities, deliberate generalization, and most important, active exploration and conjecture.

Kieran and Chalouh (1993): Algebraic thinking involves the development of mathematical reasoning within an algebraic frame of mind by building meaning for the symbols and operations of algebra in terms of arithmetic

LUMR Project (Driscoll, 1997): The facility with algebraic thinking includes the ability to think about functions and how they work and to think about the impact on calculations a system’s structure has.

NCTM Standards (5-8) - Algebra (NCTM, 1989): Understand the concept of variable, expression, and equation; represent situations and number pattern with tables, graphs, verbal rules, and equations, and explore the interrelationships of these representations; analyze tables and graphs to identify properties and relationships; develop confidence in solving linear equations using concrete, informal, and formal methods; investigate inequalities and nonlinear equations informally; apply algebraic methods to solve a variety of real-world problems and mathematical problems.

NCTM Standards (5-8) - Patterns and Functions (NCTM, 1989): Describe, extend, analyze, and create a wide variety of patterns; describe and represent relationships with tables, graphs, rules; analyze functional relationships to explain how a change in one quantity results in a change in another; use patterns and functions to represent and solve problems.

Usiskin (1997): Algebra is a language. This language has five major aspects: (1) unknowns, (2) formulas, (3) generalized patterns, (4) placeholders, (5) relationships. At any time that these ideas are discussed from kindergarten upward, there is opportunity to introduce the language of algebra.

Vance (1998): Algebra is sometimes defined as generalized arithmetic or as a language for generalizing arithmetic. However algebraic more than a set of rules for manipulating symbols: it is a way of thinking."

From Concepts in the Middle School:  Kregler, Shelley.  A special edition of Mathematics Teaching in the Middle School.

http://blog.coreknowledge.org/2010/10/06/singapore-math-is-our-dirty-little-secret/

                 

                                         Algebraic Play

                                            


                                   "Why Learn Algebra?" 

   Early Childhood Mathematics:  Promoting Good Beginnings.” 

 “Children become intensely engaged in play. Pursuing their own purposes, they tend to tackle problems that are challenging enough to be engrossing yet not totally beyond their capacities. Sticking with a problem—puzzling over it and approaching it in various ways—can lead to powerful learning. In addition, when several children grapple with the same problem, they often come up with different approaches, discuss, and learn from one another [74, 75]. These aspects of play tend to prompt and promote thinking and learning in mathematics and in other areas. 

 “Block building offers one example of play’s value for mathematical learning. As children build with blocks, they constantly accumulate experiences with the ways in which objects can be related, and these experiences become the foundation for a multitude of mathematical concepts—far beyond simply sorting and seriating. Classic unit blocks and other construction materials such as connecting blocks give children entry into a world where objects have predictable similarities and relationships [66, 76]. 


From a joint position statement (section eight) of the National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC) and the National Council for Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) Adopted in 2002 .



"Supporting [all] Students in Mathematics Through the Use of Manipulatives"

"Is it possible for all children to become mathematically literate? To achieve this goal of mathematics literacy and to meet the needs of all children requires a change in our thinking about the framework of mathematics curricula and how children learn mathematics.

"The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics’ (NCTM) Curriculum and Evaluation Standards for School Mathematics in 1989 and its revised framework of Principles and Standards for School Mathematics in 2000 provides a vision for all students to think mathematically and highlights learning by all students….

"Mathematical tools—whether concrete manipulatives or virtual manipulatives—are supportive tools for learning. The use of mathematical tools shapes the way students think and build mathematical relationships and connections toward conceptual understanding (Fuson et al.1992). Selecting and accessing the appropriate tools and processes for students with disabilities is critical to their understanding mathematics."

From Supporting Students in Mathematics Through the Use of Manipulatives:  Terry Anstrom, American Institutes for Research, 2006.

http://www.cited.org/library/resourcedocs/Supporting%20Students%20in%20Mathematics%20Through%20the%20Use%20of%20Manipulatives.pd 


                                            

© Michael S. Sommer, Ph.D, 2017